Reviewers: Submit Your Review

Please submit your review through the ScholarOne online submission system: .
Guidance for reviewers
1 = lowest (e.g., reject)
5 = average (e.g., accept with major modifications)
10 = highest (e.g., accept without revisions or with minor revisions)

Review Evaluation Form
NOTE: After your submission, a confirmation email together with the review form will be sent to you for your record.
Your Name:
Your Email:

For AuthId enabled: ( :zap emailfrom="":)

Your Name:

( :zap reviewername="":) ( :zap revieweremail="":) ( :ifend:)

Paper Number:
Paper Title:
Version Reviewed:
Special Issue?: <--Check this out!
Topic for AIEDAM:
Style and Organization:
Technical Quality:
Research Evaluation:
Overall Consideration:
Consider it as:
Your Confidence in Your Evaluation:
Comments to the Editor (will not be seen by the Author(s)):
Comments to the Author(s): Quality of Writing, Figures & References:
Number of AIEDAM Papers Cited:
Comments to the Author(s): Extra References to AIEDAM Papers:
Comments to the Author(s): Technical Review:

(Please check that you have entered ALL the information above)

Thank you very much for completing the AIEDAM Review Form!

Retrieved from
Page last modified on January 09, 2014, at 12:12 PM